The most common mistake on the green is not a bad read, but a shaky grip. Many golfers ditch the short stick entirely, opting for an anchor-free approach that turns a twitchy stroke into a pendulum of precision.
The Best Broomstick Putters represent a return to fundamental mechanics. These long-shafted tools remove the small muscles from the equation, keeping your path quiet and consistent. Let’s evaluate the current field to see which one fits your setup.
Key Takeaways
- Match your shaft length to your height to ensure the grip end rests comfortably near your sternum.
- Choose a mallet head if you need extra stability and a high moment of inertia to resist twisting.
- Prioritize face milling technology to ensure a consistent roll regardless of where you strike the ball.
- Verify your preferred stance, as some designs require a face-on position while others function with a traditional side-on setup.
- Examine the balance point of the shaft, as head weight distribution impacts how much you feel the putter during the swing.
| Ultimate Stability Choice |  |
Bell 360 Face-On Long Putter | Excellent stroke stability | Glare-free matte surface | Simplifies putting mechanics | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Superior Distance Control | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 48" | Smooth impact feel | Ideal length for posture | Consistent roll speed | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Refined Pendulum Stroke | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 46" | Milled face pattern | Slightly more maneuverable | Consistent speed control | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Southpaw Precision Tool |  |
Bell III Left Hand Putter | Left-handed orientation | Durable polished finish | Consistent mallet weighting | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Alignment Perfection Focus |  |
Odyssey Square to Square Putter | Built-in alignment guides | Reduces face rotation | Promotes square impact | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Comfort Upgrade Essential |  |
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip | High-comfort material | Vibration dampening | Two-piece modular design | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Modern Mallet Standard |  |
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11 | Deep face milling | Excellent roll characteristics | Traditional head profile | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Maximum Forgiveness Choice |  |
TaylorMade Spider X Putter | Extremely high forgiveness | Superior alignment aids | Stable head design | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Classic Blade Performance | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8 | Compact blade profile | High-sensitivity feedback | Precise distance control | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Best Value Performer |  |
Wilson Infinite Buckingham Putter | Great value | Heavy head stability | Glare-reducing finish | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Bell 360 Face-On Long Putter
If you struggle with the yips, this putter acts like a steady anchor for your stroke. Its face-on design promotes a pendulum motion that keeps your shoulders level throughout the swing. You will appreciate how the matte finish prevents glare when you stand over those high-pressure putts.
The unconventional setup requires a brief adjustment period if you are used to traditional blades. However, the consistency gained by removing wrist breakdown makes it worth the effort. It is a serious tool for golfers who want to simplify their mechanics.
- Brand:Bell
- Model:360
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Finish:Matte
- Additional Feature:Pendulum motion design
- Additional Feature:Face-on putting style
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight distribution
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 48"
This 48-inch model offers the length you need to keep your posture upright and your eyes directly over the ball. The Soft 2 model face technology provides a satisfying, muted click at impact. It feels like a surgical instrument in your hands when you need to lag from long range.
Length is its primary weapon, but you should ensure your bag can accommodate the extra height. It excels for players who prefer a stable, grounded stance rather than hunched over the ball.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:Huntington Beach Soft 2#11
- Shaft Length:48 inches
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Speed-optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Soft feel insert
- Additional Feature:High moment of inertia
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 46"
Slightly shorter than its sibling, the 46-inch version provides a more intimate connection to the ball. It retains the same high-quality milling that keeps the ball tracking straight toward the cup. This is a reliable companion for those who find 48 inches just a bit too unwieldy.
You get all the benefits of the Soft 2 head design without the extreme length of a full broomstick. It is perfect if you want to experiment with a longer stroke while maintaining some familiarity.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:Huntington Beach Soft 2#11
- Shaft Length:46 inches
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Precision milled face
- Additional Feature:Soft impact feedback
- Additional Feature:Optimized weight balancing
-
Bell III Left Hand Putter
Finding quality broomstick options as a left-handed golfer can be frustrating. This model solves that problem with a polished mallet head designed specifically for your needs. It offers the same pendulum-like consistency found in the right-handed versions.
The polished finish looks sharp and resists wear over time. While the weight is substantial, it serves to keep the stroke path locked on target throughout the follow-through.
- Brand:Bell
- Model:III 365
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Handedness:Left Hand
- Finish:Polished
- Additional Feature:Face-on design
- Additional Feature:Belly-style grip compatibility
- Additional Feature:High-stability head
-
Odyssey Square to Square Putter
This putter removes the guesswork from your setup by forcing a square strike. Its unique design acts like training wheels for your takeaway, keeping the face perpendicular to your target line. You will notice how the high-contrast alignment aids help you visualize the correct path.
The head shape is unconventional, but it excels at reducing face rotation. Use this if you find yourself pushing or pulling putts due to an inconsistent wrist action.
- Brand:Odyssey Golf
- Model:Square to Square
- Additional Feature:High-contrast visual aids
- Additional Feature:Face-balanced weight
- Additional Feature:Stroke path correction
-
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip
Sometimes your current broomstick just needs a better feel. This two-piece grip provides the cushioned texture necessary for long-shafted putters. It dampens vibration effectively, making every strike feel buttery smooth instead of harsh.
Installing a two-piece system allows for more flexibility in your hand placement. It is a cost-effective way to breathe new life into an aging broomstick setup.
- Brand:Winn
- Model:Excel
- Additional Feature:Tackier grip surface
- Additional Feature:Ergonomic hand positioning
- Additional Feature:Weather-resistant construction
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11
The Model 11 is a workhorse for golfers who prefer a traditional head shape with modern face tech. Its deep grooves help the ball roll end-over-end sooner, minimizing skidding on fast greens. It is as steady as a rock through the hitting zone.
The weighting is balanced perfectly for a smooth, rhythmic stroke. You will appreciate the clean aesthetics that avoid unnecessary visual clutter at address.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:HB Soft 2 Model 11
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Speed-optimized technology
- Additional Feature:Glare-resistant finish
- Additional Feature:Balanced head weight
-
TaylorMade Spider X Putter
The Spider X is famous for its massive footprint that stabilizes the head against off-center hits. If you struggle with inconsistent contact, this putter serves as a safety net for your game. The weight distribution pushes the center of gravity back to keep the ball online.
The visual alignment lines are some of the best in the industry. While it is not a traditional long broomstick, it is the perfect middle ground for those who want stability without extreme shaft lengths.
- Brand:TaylorMade Golf
- Model:Spider X
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:True Path alignment
- Additional Feature:Multi-material construction
- Additional Feature:Perimeter weighting
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8
If you prefer the look of a blade but want the tech of a mallet, this is your answer. The Model 8 provides a responsive feel that allows you to judge pace with precision. It is like a fine-tuned violin that rewards delicate touch.
The compact head size makes it easy to control on tricky, breaking greens. You get the benefits of the Soft 2 face without the bulky profile of larger putters.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:HB Soft 2 Model 8
- Head Shape:Blade
- Additional Feature:Speed-optimized face
- Additional Feature:Sleek modern finish
- Additional Feature:Balanced swing weight
-
Wilson Infinite Buckingham Putter
The Buckingham delivers serious results without the inflated price tag. Its heavy head provides a stable feel that discourages jerky movements during your stroke. It is a reliable underdog that holds its own against much more expensive equipment.
The dark, matte finish looks great and does a fantastic job of reducing distractions. This is a smart choice if you want professional features on a budget.
- Brand:Wilson
- Model:Infinite Buckingham
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Counterbalanced technology
- Additional Feature:Parallel alignment lines
- Additional Feature:Responsive face insert
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a broomstick putter make putting easier?
Many golfers find that these putters simplify the stroke by removing wrist action. By pinning the shaft to your chest, you turn your shoulders into the primary engine of the swing. It acts like a steady hinge on a door, keeping your path straight and repeatable.
Is it legal to anchor the putter against my body?
You can hold the putter against your body, but you cannot create a fixed anchor point that prevents the club from moving. The USGA rules prohibit you from pressing the grip against your sternum to create a fulcrum. You must keep a small gap between the grip and your body during the stroke.
How do I choose between a belly putter and a broomstick?
A belly putter is shorter and typically anchors against your stomach. A broomstick putter is much longer and is designed to reach up to your chest or chin. Choose based on whether you prefer a tucked-in feeling or a more upright, hands-high posture.
Are these putters difficult to store in a standard golf bag?
The extra length makes them awkward to manage. They will stick out significantly higher than your driver or woods. Many players use a dedicated putter tube or a shorter bag pocket to keep them from catching on other clubs.
Can I shorten a standard broomstick putter if it is too long?
You can cut the shaft, but you will drastically change the swing weight and balance. The manufacturer designed the head weight specifically for that extra length. If you alter the shaft, you might find the putter feels dead or unresponsive in your hands.
