A common mistake is choosing a lipstick by shade name alone, then discovering the color wears differently than expected. Finish, undertone, and formula can change the result as much as the pigment itself.
This guide compares the Best Nyx Lipsticks across several finishes and formats, so you can see how each option fits different makeup preferences. Keep reading for a clearer, more useful comparison.
Key Takeaways
- Check the undertone first, since warm, cool, and neutral shades can look very different on your lips.
- Choose a matte finish for a flatter look, or a satin and gloss finish for more comfort and shine.
- Review the formula claims, especially if you prefer vegan, cruelty-free, moisturizing, or non-drying lipstick.
- Pick liquid lipstick for longer wear, or a traditional bullet and crayon for faster, easier application.
- Compare the shade description and size rather than relying on product photos alone, since screen color can vary.
| Plush Color Pick |  |
NYX Butter Lipstick Taffy | Comfortable bullet format | Playful Taffy shade | Easy everyday application | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Extended Matte Wear |  |
NYX Lip Lingerie XXL Warm Up | Red-rose color | Matte liquid finish | Long-lasting positioning | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Soft Mauve Staple |  |
NYX Soft Matte Lip Cream Budapest | Deep mauve shade | Red undertone | Lightweight liquid format | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Satin Comfort Color |  |
NYX Shout Loud Satin In Love | Pink-mauve shade | Satin finish | Shea butter infused | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Classic Pink Matte |  |
NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey | Mid-tone pink shade | Clean matte finish | Familiar bullet format | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Smoothing Nude Crayon |  |
NYX Fat Matte Lipstick Rose Robe | Rose-nude shade | Pigmented color | Smoothing crayon format | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Gloss-Topped Long Wear |  |
NYX Shine Loud Magic Maker | Dusty nude-mauve shade | Clear gloss included | Long-lasting color base | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Vivid Suede Fuchsia |  |
NYX Suede Matte Lipstick Sweet Tooth | Vivid fuchsia shade | Suede matte finish | Vegan formula | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Peachy Creamy Neutral |  |
NYX Extra Creamy Round Cocoa | Cocoa shade | Peach undertones | Extra-creamy formula | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Compact Peachy Pink |  |
NYX Butter Lipstick Candy Buttons | Peachy-pink shade | Creamy butter formula | Clearly listed size | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
NYX Butter Lipstick Taffy
Choose this butter lipstick if you prefer a traditional bullet with a softer, more comfortable feel. The Taffy shade gives your makeup collection a playful option for everyday color or a brighter layered look.
Its main appeal is the creamy format, which is easy to apply without liquid-lipstick precision. The limitation is that the available listing provides few formula details, so you should not expect confirmed wear time or finish information.
- Brand:NYX
- Product Type:Butter lipstick
- Shade Name:Taffy
- Formula:Butter formula
- Additional Feature:Traditional lipstick bullet
- Additional Feature:Creamy butter-style formula
- Additional Feature:Playful color option
-
NYX Lip Lingerie XXL Warm Up
For a long-wearing liquid lip, this shade suits you if you want a defined red-rose look with less frequent touch-ups. Warm Up brings a sophisticated color direction that works well for evening makeup and polished office looks.
The matte finish offers a clean, statement-making result, while the liquid format supports precise application around the lip line. Matte formulas can feel less comfortable on dry lips, and the listing does not provide specific wear-time details beyond its long-lasting positioning.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Liquid lipstick
- Shade Name:Warm Up
- Finish:Matte
- Formula:Long-wearing liquid
- Additional Feature:XXL Lip Lingerie formula
- Additional Feature:Red-rose shade direction
- Additional Feature:Precise liquid application
-
NYX Soft Matte Lip Cream Budapest
Budapest is a strong choice for deep mauve color with a noticeable red undertone. You will likely appreciate it if you want a defined lip that feels lighter than a traditional heavy liquid lipstick.
The soft matte finish keeps the look modern without adding shine, and the lightweight format is suited to comfortable daily wear. The tradeoff is that a deeper matte shade may need careful, even application to look smooth.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Liquid lipstick
- Shade Name:Budapest
- Finish:Soft matte
- Formula:Lightweight liquid
- Additional Feature:Red-undertone color
- Additional Feature:Soft matte result
- Additional Feature:Lightweight feel
-
NYX Shout Loud Satin In Love
If you prefer lipstick with soft shine, In Love offers a pink-mauve shade in a classic satin format. It is a practical pick for you if comfort and easy reapplication matter more than a fully matte finish.
The shea butter infusion points to a more conditioning feel, while the satin finish adds dimension to the lips. Satin color generally needs more frequent refreshing than matte formulas, so it may not be your first choice for maximum staying power.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Satin lipstick
- Shade Name:In Love
- Finish:Satin
- Formula:Shea butter infused
- Additional Feature:Traditional lipstick format
- Additional Feature:Soft pink-mauve color
- Additional Feature:Conditioning formula focus
-
NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey
Audrey fits a classic pink lipstick brief, especially if you want a mid-tone shade that adds color without moving into deep berry or red territory. Its familiar bullet format makes it easy to use for office makeup, daytime looks, or a polished evening lip.
The matte finish gives the shade a cleaner, more defined appearance with minimal shine. As with many matte lipsticks, you may want to prep dry lips first because the listing does not identify added moisturizing ingredients.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Matte lipstick
- Shade Name:Audrey
- Finish:Matte
- Formula:Matte
- Additional Feature:Blue-pink color direction
- Additional Feature:Traditional lipstick bullet
- Additional Feature:Defined low-shine finish
-
NYX Fat Matte Lipstick Rose Robe
Rose Robe is made for you if you want a rose-nude lip with the control of a crayon. The wider format can make filling in the lips quick, while the listing highlights pigmentation and a smoothing, non-drying approach.
Its vegan and cruelty-free positioning adds appeal if those standards guide your purchases. The limitation is that a larger crayon tip may offer less precision than a slim lipstick or liquid applicator, particularly at the cupid’s bow.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Matte lip crayon
- Shade Name:Rose Robe
- Finish:Matte
- Formula:Non-drying
- Additional Feature:Vegan formula
- Additional Feature:Cruelty-free formula
- Additional Feature:Long-lasting positioning
-
NYX Shine Loud Magic Maker
Magic Maker suits you if you want dusty nude-mauve color with a glossy topcoat effect. The two-part concept gives you a way to create a shine-forward finish while keeping the base more defined than a standard gloss.
The long-lasting liquid lipstick base is paired with a clear lip gloss, making this a flexible choice for bold shine. That extra step can add application time, and the glossy layer may require more upkeep than the color layer.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Liquid lipstick
- Shade Name:Magic Maker
- Finish:Glossy topcoat
- Formula:Long-lasting liquid
- Additional Feature:Clear lip gloss included
- Additional Feature:Two-step lip system
- Additional Feature:Dusty nude-mauve color
-
NYX Suede Matte Lipstick Sweet Tooth
Sweet Tooth is the pick for a vivid fuchsia lip with a soft-looking matte effect. You will get the most from it if your makeup style favors noticeable color rather than understated nude shades.
The suede matte finish aims for a plush appearance without visible gloss, and the vegan formula may appeal to ingredient-conscious shoppers. Bright matte colors can reveal uneven texture, so smooth lip preparation will help the result look more polished.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Matte lipstick
- Shade Name:Sweet Tooth
- Finish:Suede matte
- Formula:Vegan
- Additional Feature:Bright fuchsia color
- Additional Feature:Traditional lipstick format
- Additional Feature:Soft suede appearance
-
NYX Extra Creamy Round Cocoa
Cocoa is a good match for you if you prefer a creamy neutral with peach undertones. The extra-creamy format should feel approachable for daily use, especially when you want color that looks softer than a flat matte.
Its round lipstick design keeps application straightforward, while the warm cocoa shade adds gentle definition. Creamier formulas typically offer less resistance to transfer than matte options, so plan on refreshing it after eating or drinking.
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product Type:Creamy round lipstick
- Shade Name:Cocoa
- Formula:Extra creamy
- Additional Feature:Peach-undertone color
- Additional Feature:Round lipstick format
- Additional Feature:Soft everyday color
-
NYX Butter Lipstick Candy Buttons
Candy Buttons is aimed at you if you like a peachy pink lip in a familiar bullet format. The shade has a lighter, playful direction that works well with fresh daytime makeup and soft blush tones.
The butter lipstick formula is positioned around a creamy feel, while the listed 0.16-ounce size gives you a clear sense of the product quantity. The available information does not confirm the finish or expected wear time, so this is better suited to shoppers who value shade and format over performance claims.
- Brand:NYX
- Product Type:Butter lipstick
- Shade Name:Candy Buttons
- Formula:Butter formula
- Size:0.16 ounce
- Additional Feature:Traditional lipstick bullet
- Additional Feature:Peachy-pink color direction
- Additional Feature:Compact 0.16-ounce size
Frequently Asked Questions
Which NYX lipstick lasts the longest?
Shine Loud is one of NYX’s strongest choices for extended wear because it uses a pigmented color layer followed by a gloss topcoat. It is designed to resist transfer better than standard cream lipsticks and glosses. Your application still affects performance. Start with clean, dry lips, use a thin color layer, and allow it to set before applying the topcoat.
Is NYX lipstick suitable for dry lips?
Yes, but the best option is usually a glossy or creamy formula rather than an intensely matte liquid lipstick. Butter Gloss and similar hydrating-feeling products are less likely to highlight flakes. Prep with a light lip balm, then blot away excess before applying color. Heavy balm underneath can reduce staying power and cause some formulas to slide.
Does NYX lipstick transfer?
It depends on the formula. Glosses and cream lipsticks commonly transfer onto cups or masks, while products labeled transfer-resistant are designed to leave less color behind after they set. Even long-wear formulas may move with oily foods, moisture, or repeated rubbing. A thin application and careful setting usually produce the cleanest result.
How do you choose the right NYX lipstick shade?
Start with your undertone and intended use. Blue-based reds and rosy pinks often suit cooler undertones, while peach, terracotta, and warm brown shades tend to complement warmer undertones. Neutral shades can work across a wider range. For online shopping, compare several swatches and read customer comments about pigmentation. If you want one versatile option, a medium rose, soft berry, or neutral brown is usually easier to wear than an extremely pale nude.
Is NYX lipstick cruelty-free?
NYX Professional Makeup states that its products are cruelty-free, but product availability and brand policies can change. Check the brand’s current official policy and the retailer listing before purchasing if this is a deciding factor. You should also review the ingredient list for personal allergies or sensitivities. Cruelty-free status does not mean a product is suitable for every skin type.
